(06-29-2019, 09:01 PM)Shiver Metimbers Wrote: The "spark" was me objecting to Rapinoe et al. inserting their personal politics into what should be simply Sports, and doing so in a most egregiously inappropriate way:
(06-28-2019, 04:05 PM)Shiver Metimbers Wrote: Off-topic warning, can't keep quiet about this though.
Rapinoe, star of the US Women's Team currently playing in the Women's World Cup in France, has failed again to show proper respect and honor for the country that has done so much for her. Joined by many of her teammates, no hand over heart nor singing of the national anthem before the game.
What a contrast with every other team on the planet, and especially host France. Their team, every single one, and most of the fans sang La Marseillaise with gusto.
NFL lost my patronage years ago over this behavior, but at least those players and teams are private organizations. THIS team, like the Olympic teams, is NOT.
[EDIT: on re-reading, I realize I left an incorrect impression. Neither Olympic athletes, nor national team soccer players are funded by taxpayer money. So, in that sense they are "private." However, they are wearing US colors and represent this nation in an international Arena. In that sense they are very much not private.]
Fine, you don't respect me, right back at ya. Will be rooting for the Frogs.
OK sorry, back to regularly scheduled paint-drying.
This was followed by a Straw-Man argument that back-handedly accused me of hypocritically "wrapping myself in the flag" and then hypocritically/improperly being "unhappy" about some fellow American "expressing their opinion" when America is "supposed to be about freedom from conformity."
(06-28-2019, 07:57 PM)tuzo29 Wrote: I've never understood those who are proud to be an American but then are unhappy when other Americans express their differing opinions. I'm pretty sure our country is founded on freedom and liberty rather than conformity and unity of thought. I'm all for those who want to express their differing views (NFL players and Rapinoe), especially if they do it respectfully like Kaepernick. (I didn't watch Rapinoe during anthem, maybe her, too). That's the whole point of the American experiment, right?
So going back to your old posts, this once seems to be important since you created a new topic/thread for it. I think I understand your perspective. All Americans should respect the flag and national anthem what they stand for. Please let me know if I'm wrong here.
This is a very broad topic with lots of potential for tangents and rabbit holes. To simply respond to your comments here, I'll start with my assumption that you were not happy with. I assumed that expecting those representing our country to conform to the standard forms of national pride and respect meant that you had national pride. I'm not sure how we got to the point where this is the argument. I'm sorry I made an assumption about your level of national pride. I think (another assumption coming, but I have to start somewhere) that you read something in my words that I did not intend. I only wanted to say that it appeared you have a respect for the flag and the national anthem and simplified that to "proud to be an American". You clearly read more into it that I was trying to say. For the record, I'm proud to be an American. I'm not proud of everything America has done, but I doubt anyone is.
So on to my only point on this topic. The first amendment gives Americans the right to protest. How we protest can come in many forms. I think that Kaepernick and Rapinoe and many others choosing not to stand and/or sing the national anthem is a very American thing to do. They are protesting their government/society and the founding fathers wrote that protesting is a right into the Constitution because they knew it was a needed thing for a society to survive. You are correct that these professional athletes have been given a lot by our country. That shouldn't take away their right to protest if they are unhappy with something. I think (again, correct me if I'm making a wrong assumption here) that you find the timing of their protestations to be the problem. That is, they shouldn't do it in front of crowds at a sporting event when they are representing their country. My view is that if we start telling people when they get their Constitutional rights and when they don't get them, then they aren't really rights.